Spanish Bishops Withhold Joint Word on Nov. 29 Vote
Plenary accounts clash on a failed draft and a possible Leo XIV paragraph as Spain heads to early polls.
The 130th plenary assembly of the Spanish Episcopal Conference, meeting in Madrid from Nov. 16 through Friday, Nov. 20, will not issue a full joint note on the Nov. 29 general election. Accounts from the assembly differ on whether any shorter text cleared the floor and on why a longer draft stalled.
A draft without two-thirds support
On the afternoon of Monday, Nov. 16, bishops voted on a draft note presented by the presidency. The text is described as having won only a relative majority, short of the two-thirds required for publication as an Assembly document. The Executive Commission had earlier failed to approve it.
Plenary sources characterize the failed text as heavily diluted, omitting direct reference to abortion, marriage, or education. Three currents were said to be at work: bishops aligned with Conference president Archbishop Luis Argüello, who sought criteria drawn from Pope Leo XIV’s address to the Spanish parliament; a neutrality camp associated with the approach of Cardinals Ricardo Blázquez and Juan José Omella; and an intermediate group willing only to accept general language that avoided abortion, euthanasia, Ceuta, and publicly subsidized schooling.
One bishop summed up the outcome: “It has been decided not to interfere in the elections, much less in terms that would place us, in the eyes of public opinion, as guides of the vote for the right and the far right.” As of midweek, the Conference had not formally announced the result of the vote.
A possible paragraph on Leo XIV
Other voices from the same Monday session report a different decision: that bishops approved a single paragraph referring directly to the Pope’s remarks in Madrid, after setting aside a longer draft following “a fraternal debate.” That paragraph was expected to be made public at the closing press conference on Friday.
A bishop supporting that reading said: “Leo XIV was clear enough in setting out all the issues that may matter for a Catholic deciding how to vote.”
In his opening address on Nov. 16, Archbishop Argüello had left the door open: “I do not want to make a direct reference now to the upcoming general elections, since I hope this Assembly can offer some statement on the matter.”
Context and the Pope’s June words
The last full collegial guidance for a Spanish general election was the 2011 moral guidance note, issued by the Permanent Commission under Cardinal Antonio María Rouco Varela a month before the Nov. 20, 2011 vote. Neither Cardinal Blázquez, who faced four general elections as president, nor Cardinal Omella, president at the 2023 vote, issued a comparable text. The Nov. 29 ballot was called early by Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez.
The debate turns in part on Leo XIV’s June 8 address to the Spanish parliament, in which he stated that the defense of human life “never constitutes a partisan position nor responds to a strictly confessional interest.” Bishops who favored stronger language saw those words as a mandate to name non-negotiable goods—life, marriage, and education—without endorsing any party. Others judged any pre-election note, however carefully worded, as risking the appearance of electoral guidance.
Whether Friday’s closing brings only silence, a brief paragraph, or a later clarification, the Assembly’s difficulty in speaking with one voice underscores how contested the Church’s public word remains when Spain votes.