Sunday, November 22, 2026
CathoNews
Catholic news, faithful to Rome

Retired CAF Chaplain General Defends Naming God

Father Guy Chapdelaine says state neutrality is not silence and warns that uneven spiritual rules risk unfairness in the ranks.

Major-General (Ret’d) Father Guy Chapdelaine, former Chaplain General of the Canadian Armed Forces, has publicly opposed a CAF policy that bars military chaplains from mentioning God in certain spiritual reflections at official gatherings where attendance is mandatory.

In an open letter dated for publication on November 18, 2026, the priest argues that the measure is presented as an application of state neutrality but misreads what neutrality requires.

“The real question, however, is whether neutrality requires the complete removal of religious references from the military public sphere. In my view, the answer is no,” he writes. “State neutrality means that government does not favor one religion over another. It does not mean that all religious expression must disappear.”

Neutrality, inclusion, and double standards

Chapdelaine notes that Indigenous spiritual traditions are “recognized and openly honored” at many official events. He asks why a Christian, Jewish, Muslim, or Sikh chaplain should not be allowed, “with the same respect, to refer to God when addressing those seeking spiritual support.”

A policy that permits some forms of spiritual expression while excluding others, he warns, “risks creating a sense of unfairness rather than fostering inclusion.” He presses the point with a national symbol: should “O Canada” cease to be sung at certain ceremonies because the English lyrics include “God keep our land glorious and free”?

The letter does not state the date on which the CAF decision was taken. It frames the ban within wider institutional strain. The Forces, Chapdelaine writes, face “significant challenges related to recruitment, retention, and operational readiness.” Some recent choices, he says, leave the impression that “the response is to lower certain standards rather than strengthen the institution,” a critique he links also to debates over bilingualism and the place of French.

Chaplains beside suffering and death

Chaplains, he insists, accompany members who confront “suffering, loss, fear, and sometimes death.” Their role “is not to impose a faith but to support individuals according to their needs and convictions.” Inclusion, he concludes, “does not mean asking people to remain silent about what matters most to them.”

For Catholics who serve or minister in the military, the dispute touches the Church’s teaching that religious freedom includes public witness, not only private belief, and that authentic pluralism does not demand the erasure of God from the public square. Chapdelaine’s intervention places that principle squarely inside Canada’s armed forces: chaplains present for duty, he argues, must still be free to name the One to whom believers pray when the institution itself summons them to speak.

NEXT STORYSt. Romero Named Patron of Central American Bishops