Colombia Court Backs President's Fatima Crowning
Judges found the quake-victims vigil had a secular aim and that "viva Cristo Rey" is free expression, not state doctrine.
In a ruling published November 13, 2026, the Fifth Section of Colombia’s Council of State held that President Abelardo de la Espriella did not breach the religious neutrality and secularism of the state when he crowned an image of Our Lady of Fatima at a candlelight vigil for victims of the August 10, 2026, earthquake.
The case began with a constitutional protection suit filed October 14 by Román Camilo Díaz Fernández. The plaintiff argued that the president and ministers had violated equality, freedom of worship and conscience, the right of petition, and the principles of secularism and institutional neutrality. The complaint also challenged the president’s use of the phrase “viva Cristo Rey,” his September visit to the Bet-El synagogue in Barranquilla, where he wore a kippah; Culture Minister Paola Holguín over funding for the large candlelight vigil at which religious acts took place; and former Interior Minister Rodrigo Lara over statements on X and at the Centro Israelita de Bogotá affirming that Colombia guarantees the security and freedom of worship of the Jewish community.
Secular purpose of the vigil
The Council found that the coronation “does not, per se, disregard the principles of neutrality and secularism because said act was part of a day that had an important secular justification,” namely “institutional and social mobilization in humanitarian support for the victims.” It added that the president “did not issue any statement, did not privilege nor urge adherence to the Catholic religion or any other creed.”
On “viva Cristo Rey,” the chamber ruled that “expressing an intimate or cultural conviction through that phrase at a public act is not equivalent to dictating a norm, issuing an administrative act or establishing an obligation of adherence for citizens.” As a citizen, the president “is not stripped of his rights to freedom of conscience, worship and expression.”
Citing the Constitutional Court, the Council distinguished institutional neutrality—which bars the state from imposing or privileging a religion—from the individual freedom of public officials, provided their personal expressions do not become official acts of religious adherence or discrimination. It also noted that the Bogotá Superior Tribunal had earlier found the phrase did not violate freedom of conscience and worship.
Culture funds and statements on Jewish worship
Ministry of Culture funds “cannot be interpreted as a favoring of the Catholic religion,” the Council said, because their use had “a clear contractual motivation and a specific secular purpose” to “make visible an event of public interest.”
Regarding former Interior Minister Lara, the chamber observed that his remarks were made in commemoration of the “anti‑Semitic attack perpetrated by Hamas on October 7, 2023,” and that he told attendees “that they should not feel fear for professing their faith.” Absent any administrative act or coercive action amounting to doctrinal or religious interference, “the Chamber does not find a violation of the fundamental rights invoked.”
The decision separates the state’s duty of institutional neutrality from the legitimate public exercise of faith by officials acting as citizens—an outcome of clear interest for Catholics concerned that secularism not be used to silence Christian witness in civic life.