Exonerated Catholic Presses Florida to End Executions
Joined by fellow exonerees, Joaquín José Martínez urged Gov.-elect Byron Donalds to halt executions as Florida bishops continue to call for mercy.
On November 12, Joaquín José Martínez—a Spanish-born Catholic once condemned to die in Florida and later cleared—stood with fellow exonerees and urged Governor-elect Byron Donalds to halt executions in the state.
Martínez was convicted of murder in 1997, sentenced to death, and exonerated in 2001. He was joined at the press conference by Herman Lindsey and Seth Penalver. He acknowledged that it is “difficult” for many people to “accept that the death penalty is not perfect.” “It has faults,” he said. “I’m one more reason why we should abolish the death penalty.”
A long campaign, a changed landscape
A longtime advocate against capital punishment in Florida and beyond, Martínez said he takes “the long view”: “One step at a time.” He regularly speaks in schools about abolition. He described a sociopolitical shift since his youth: “We didn’t have anyone come out [when I was a child] to teach us and speak to us about how horrible the death penalty was. To see this change now, I’m overwhelmed by it.”
Florida has been among the most active states carrying out executions, with 23 executions there over the last year alone, according to figures from the Death Penalty Information Center. Catholic bishops in Florida have repeatedly opposed executions and stressed the humanity of the condemned. In 2025 they called for the commutation of one death sentence, arguing that the governor should “recognize with awe that God is the author of life, and to reserve to him the taking of human life except where it is otherwise impossible to maintain the common good.”
Martínez said he loves his adopted country and “would really love to see the United States put an end to the death penalty,” adding, “I think we’re an example to the rest of the world.” At the press conference he likened U.S. executions to spectacles in ancient Rome’s Colosseum—“I mean, how barbaric!”—while insisting the United States and Florida “are not barbaric” but “just need to evolve. It just needs to grow.”
Unity, media, and signs of change
He said the anti-death-penalty movement is far more united and focused than when he sat on death row, when “we didn’t have so many organizations working together against the death penalty,” and that coverage is fairer now. Pointing to California Gov. Gavin Newsom’s recent action clearing every prisoner on that state’s death row, he concluded: “It’s going to take a long time to change. But we do see change. It’s good.”
Catholics and other advocates have pressed Florida officials for years to stop executions. Martínez’s appeal to the incoming governor renews that call as the state continues to schedule capital sentences—and as the Church’s teaching on the dignity of every human life remains the measure by which many of the faithful judge the practice.