Australian Bishops Urge Dropping Online Duty Bill
Bishop Percy calls the bill fundamentally flawed, warning vague harm rules could label Catholic teaching on sex and family as harmful to children.
Australia’s Catholic bishops have warned that a federal online-safety bill meant to protect children could chill religious speech and push platforms to scrub traditional Christian teaching from the public square.
In a submission to a Senate inquiry earlier this month, the Australian Catholic Bishops Conference said the Online Safety Amendment (Digital Duty of Care) Bill 2026 is “fundamentally flawed” and “should be abandoned.” Sydney Bishop Tony Percy, speaking for the conference, insisted the legislation “should focus entirely on the need for protecting our children, not restricting adults in freedom of religion, freedom of expression, and legitimate, mature debate.”
The bill has already cleared the Lower House. Communications Minister Anika Wells is pressing for Senate passage before the end of the year. Rules would take effect 12 months after royal assent. Online providers face civil penalties of up to $21.84 million. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese defended the measure in October, saying it “puts a positive obligation on Big Tech” to keep the online environment safe.
Five Core Objections
The bishops list five principal reservations. First, “excluded material” covers professional news, education, and public-interest content but not religious teaching. Platforms would therefore take a “highly cautious and risk-averse approach” and treat catechesis, Scripture, and moral doctrine as potentially “harmful to children.”
Second, the definition of harm is open-ended. Section 25E(1)(c) treats material that promotes “hostile attitudes towards women or gender equality” as harmful without defining those terms. Traditional teaching on ethics, relationships, marriage, and human sexuality could therefore be “easily deemed harmful.”
Third, the state “should not assume primary responsibility for determining the moral values to which children may be exposed.” Parents and the Church, not regulators, hold that duty.
Fourth, while the conference shares concern over manipulative algorithms, it demands “a clear distinction between protecting users from manipulative design practices and controlling the content they are permitted to access.”
Fifth, the penalty and reporting regime, built for large technology firms, is ill-suited to parishes, dioceses, and small Catholic community organizations that maintain modest websites or social-media pages.
Religious Freedom at Stake
Bishop Percy underscored that “the right to religious freedom is the second most important human right after the right to life.” Anglican Bishop Michael Stead, in a separate submission, pointed to the United Kingdom’s experience, which he said “has proven disastrous for freedom of expression” and produced “a default model of suppression of speech and expression.”
The bill has drawn criticism from religious bodies, free-speech advocates, and other civil-society groups. For Catholics who form conscience through clear teaching on the dignity of life, marriage, and the family, the practical risk is not abstract: platforms under heavy fines will default to removing content that regulators might later label harmful. The bishops’ call is therefore straightforward—protect children without silencing the Gospel online.