Liturgist Weighs Lay Gestures at the Our Father
Fr. McNamara says silent rubrics mean no added gestures—and finds hand-holding more distracting than the orans posture.
Days after the Archdiocese of Portland urged the faithful not to raise or join hands during the Lord’s Prayer at Mass, a detailed liturgical reading has sharpened the stakes of that guidance.
In a companion Q&A dated November 15, 2026, Fr. Edward McNamara, professor of liturgy at the Regina Apostolorum, stresses that when the missal gives no posture for the assembly, “nothing is foreseen”—not an open invitation to invent gestures. The rubrics, he notes, explicitly direct the priest and concelebrants to pray the Our Father with hands extended.
Portland’s Norm and the Law
Portland’s Divine Worship Office, in its November 2026 worship newsletter, called on deacons and lay Catholics to refrain from the orans posture and from holding hands during the prayer. “Neither deacons assisting at Mass nor the lay faithful are instructed to assume this posture,” it states. The aim is not to judge private devotion but to keep distinct roles visible in the Eucharistic celebration.
The archdiocese anchors the call in the General Instruction of the Roman Missal, which specifies when the priest extends his hands; in Sacrosanctum Concilium, which forbids anyone—even a priest—from adding, removing, or changing liturgical elements on private authority; and in canon 907, which bars deacons and laypeople from prayers proper to the celebrant. It recalls that before the 1970 Missal only the priest recited the Our Father with extended hands, and that neither the revised books nor the Council altered the congregation’s posture on this point. Portland does not deny the ancient orans tradition, citing Moses in Exodus 17 and early Christian images in the Roman catacombs.
What Other Churches Have Done
McNamara observes that the Italian bishops obtained Holy See permission for an optional orans posture among the people; a 2002 U.S. proposal failed to win the required two-thirds majority; and in 2023 the Philippine bishops allowed raised hands and hand-holding where already customary, insisting both remain voluntary.
He personally finds the orans posture “not particularly problematic” for the faithful, recalling Cardinal Ratzinger’s description of it as “the oldest gesture of prayer in Christendom.” He is “less enthusiastic” about hand-holding, which can pull attention from the prayer’s God-directed sense and anticipate or weaken the Sign of Peace—a concern already raised in a 1975 reply from the Congregation for Divine Worship.
The Portland guidance thus sits within a wider debate: how to honor inherited prayer gestures without blurring the priest’s presidential role that the Church’s liturgical books carefully mark.