Sunday, November 22, 2026
CathoNews
Catholic news, faithful to Rome

St. Louis Sues Feds Over Denied Detainee Sacraments

Archbishop Rozanski says priests barred from confession, Communion, and Mass at an ICE jail seek only the space other Missouri prisons allow.

On Nov. 17, Archbishop Mitchell T. Rozanski of St. Louis said the archdiocese is suing the federal government so clergy can administer the sacraments to migrants held for Immigration and Customs Enforcement.

Speaking at the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops’ fall plenary assembly in Baltimore, he described a federal lawsuit the Archdiocese of St. Louis filed in October in the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. Court materials place the filing on Oct. 5. The action targets the Ste. Genevieve County Detention Center, which ICE uses for people awaiting deportation proceedings.

No face-to-face ministry

Rozanski said the facility’s no-contact policy has left priests unable to meet detainees face to face. About a dozen clergy who went to minister there “were only allowed to speak to the detainees on the telephone through the glass,” he said. “They were not able to hear confessions. They were not able to give them Communion. Not able to celebrate Mass. Nothing of the sacraments.”

Priests sought accommodations before the suit was filed; the facility rejected them. One proposal was to pass Communion in an envelope to be handed over on the other side of the barrier. Rozanski rejected that approach: “That’s not the way we receive Communion.”

The facility later made limited changes, including a window in a steel door, so Communion could be distributed during Mass conducted by video. The archbishop said that falls short of what the Church needs.

Space for Mass and confession

“We’re just asking for a space, as we are given in other incarceration institutions in Missouri prisons,” Rozanski said. “We’re given a space to have Mass. We’re given a space to meet for reconciliation.” He has heard confessions in other prisons without difficulty. “But it’s just in this facility.”

A central demand is that “there would be no electronic communication involved if the detainees are going to the sacrament of reconciliation,” protecting the seal of confession. He warned the dispute could have “national repercussions” for pastoral care in immigration detention.

Earlier the same day, Archbishop Paul S. Coakley of Oklahoma City, president of the bishops’ conference, listed “providing adequate pastoral and spiritual care” to detainees among the bishops’ chief concerns on migration policy.

A Department of Homeland Security spokesperson did not immediately say whether accommodations for reconciliation were planned.

The archdiocese frames the case as a request for the same sacramental access already afforded in other Missouri prisons—Mass, confession, and Communion administered in person, not through glass, phones, or envelopes—so the faithful in custody are not cut off from the means of grace the Church is bound to offer.

NEXT STORYGugerotti Urges Gaza Aid Trucks Through as Visit Opens