Sunday, November 15, 2026
CathoNews
Catholic news, faithful to Rome

Pope Hears Survivors, Not Opus Dei Claimants

Forty-three former numeraries who sought a meeting for weeks say Monday’s private encounter left them excluded and disappointed.

On Monday, November 9, Pope Leo XIV spent more than an hour at the Apostolic Nunciature in Buenos Aires with five abuse survivors presented by local Church officials. The encounter did not appear on the public schedule of the papal visit. None of the 43 former Opus Dei numerary auxiliaries who have sued in Argentina were among those received, though they had sought a hearing for weeks.

A Holy See Press Office note said the Pope spoke individually with each of the five, then gave them his blessing and thanked them for the meeting and their testimony of faith. He expressed to them — and through them to other victims he could not meet — his desire to strengthen protection, reception, and accompaniment in the Church. The Holy See did not name the five people or the cases they represent.

Former numeraries left waiting

That morning, the former numeraries released a video through Ending Clergy Abuse (ECA) saying they wanted Pope Leo XIV to listen, sought justice, and described what they endured as human trafficking. Their formal request reached the Vatican on September 15 and, they say, went unanswered; sources close to the women state that no audience was granted.

The women allege they were recruited as children or adolescents with promises of schooling and work, then spent years in unpaid domestic labor under long hours, restricted freedom, and psychological pressure. They filed a complaint with Argentine justice in September 2024. The prosecutor’s office for trafficking and exploitation (Protex) has accused members of the prelature of running a recruitment and labor-exploitation system and has sought formal questioning of five former Opus Dei leaders in Argentina. According to the women’s lawyer, Sebastián Sal, the judge has not yet summoned them. Opus Dei denies the accusations.

Reactions after the nunciature meeting

At a press conference in Buenos Aires on November 10, Andrea Martínez said the outcome was a disappointment and that the women would have liked to be received, describing the 43 as "a problem" for the Church. Elisa Carmona, who spent 15 years in that setting, spoke of labor, spiritual, and emotional abuse. ECA’s Sergio Salinas Giordano criticized the secrecy of the meeting and the undisclosed criteria for choosing the five, saying the office statement generated discontent rather than hope and that the encounter had further harmed very vulnerable victims. German survivor Matthias Katsch said survivors need respect more than a blessing. Sal also noted the Pope’s reception of Opus Dei prelate Fernando Ocáriz while the women continued to wait.

Pope Leo XIV left Argentina on Wednesday, November 11, for Peru, where he is scheduled to meet victims of the Sodalicio de Vida Cristiana in Chiclayo.

NEXT STORYLeo XIV Names Bishop Vilà Mayo Archbishop of Barcelona