Sunday, November 22, 2026
CathoNews
Catholic news, faithful to Rome

Oakland Jury Awards $14.3 Million in Abuse Case

A second eight-figure verdict this year cites former priest Stephen Kiesle; the Diocese of Oakland’s bankruptcy case remains unresolved.

A California jury has ordered the Diocese of Oakland to pay $14.3 million to a single survivor of clergy sexual abuse, identified in court as Jane Doe. The verdict, announced Nov. 17, 2026, by the survivor’s counsel, came from Alameda County Superior Court and marks the second major individual award against the diocese this year.

In April, a jury ordered the same diocese to pay $16 million to a John Doe plaintiff in a related matter. Both cases centered on former priest Stephen Kiesle, long accused of multiple acts of abuse within the diocese.

Prior Convictions and the Diocese’s Bankruptcy

Kiesle pleaded no contest in 1978 to lewd conduct involving two boys and received probation. In the early 2000s he was sentenced to six years in prison after pleading no contest to molesting a girl near Sacramento. In 2022 he was charged with vehicular manslaughter and drunk driving after a crash that killed a man in Rossmoor, California; he pleaded no contest in 2023 and was sentenced to more than six years in state prison.

Large payouts to individual victims remain relatively uncommon in U.S. diocesan abuse litigation. Dioceses more often resolve scores of claims together in bankruptcy, dividing tens or hundreds of millions of dollars among many survivors. In Oakland, individual trials were allowed to proceed separately even as the diocese’s bankruptcy case, first opened in 2023, continued.

Judge William Lafferty oversaw the latest verdict. In October he rejected a diocesan request to resolve and close the bankruptcy proceedings, finding the diocese had not met statutory requirements to end the case.

Calls for Accountability and the Diocese’s Response

Attorney Jeff Anderson, whose firm represents the plaintiff, called the verdict “a powerful reminder that when survivors stand up, speak out, and demand accountability, their voices can no longer be ignored.”

The Diocese of Oakland later acknowledged the jury’s decision. In a statement it said it “is committed to providing fair and just compensation to all Survivors, and continues to work towards that goal in the bankruptcy process.”

The Church teaches that every act of abuse of a minor is a grave crime and a profound betrayal of trust. Bishops and dioceses remain bound to protect the vulnerable, cooperate with civil justice, and ensure just reparation for survivors while safeguarding the legitimate rights of all parties under both canon and civil law. The Oakland verdict underscores the continuing civil accountability of local Churches for past failures and the unfinished work of healing and reform.

NEXT STORYRussian Strike Damages Odesa’s Catholic Cathedral