Monday, November 16, 2026
CathoNews
Catholic news, faithful to Rome

Judge Shields More NY Pro-Life Centers on Pill Reversal

Western District Judge John Sinatra's Friday order now reaches unnamed NIFLA members; ADF says James sought to keep women in the dark.

U.S. District Judge John Sinatra of the Western District of New York issued an order last Friday expanding a preliminary injunction that bars New York Attorney General Letitia James from censoring speech about abortion-pill reversal. The broader order now covers “unnamed New York members” of the National Institute of Family and Life Advocates (NIFLA) in the case National Institute of Family and Life Advocates et al. v. Letitia James.

Abortion-pill reversal refers to a protocol in which a woman who has taken the first abortion drug, mifepristone, receives the natural hormone progesterone in an effort to counteract the drug and continue the pregnancy. Heartbeat International states that progesterone “has been used for decades to safely and effectively prevent miscarriage and forestall preterm labor” and says thousands of lives have been saved through the treatment.

Speech Protection and the State’s Campaign

In a Monday statement, Gabriella McIntyre, legal counsel for Alliance Defending Freedom, said: “Many women regret their abortions, and some change their minds after taking the first abortion drug and want to try to save their unborn babies’ lives.” She added that “the New York attorney general has desperately tried to censor and keep women in the dark about abortion-pill reversal.”

In May 2024, Attorney General James sued Heartbeat International and 11 pro-life pregnancy care centers, alleging “false and misleading claims.” She stated at the time: “Abortions cannot be reversed.” Critics of the protocol include the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, which has said claims regarding abortion “reversal” treatment “are not based on science and do not meet clinical standards.”

In August 2024, the Thomas More Society sued James on behalf of Summit Life Outreach Center and The Evergreen Association. Sinatra, a Trump appointee, issued a preliminary injunction protecting several pro-life groups in September 2024. The expansion issued Friday extends that protection to additional NIFLA-affiliated centers in New York that were not previously named.

Parallel Ruling and the Defense of Life

Earlier this year, Colorado agreed to pay $6 million in legal fees to settle a challenge to a 2023 state law that barred pro-life groups from providing the treatment. U.S. District Judge Daniel Domenico, also a Trump appointee, had issued a permanent injunction, writing that “while the clinical efficacy of abortion pill reversal remains debatable, nobody has been injured by the treatment and a number of women have successfully given birth after receiving it.”

For Catholics committed to the defense of life from conception, the New York order matters because it protects the freedom of pregnancy centers to offer women who reverse course after beginning a chemical abortion information and care aimed at saving their unborn children. The Church teaches that every human life possesses inviolable dignity; counseling and medical options that seek to preserve that life after mifepristone has been taken stand within that moral tradition, even as medical and legal disputes continue.

The expanded injunction leaves James barred from enforcing her censorship effort against the covered NIFLA members while the litigation proceeds.

NEXT STORYCardinal Tobin Heals After Kidney Surgery, Trusts Christ