Catholic Mutual Sues Louisiana Dioceses on Abuse Payouts
It ended 2024 contracts, says limited aggregate coverage for abuse claims is exhausted, and omitted Alexandria amid that diocese’s bankruptcy.
The Catholic Mutual Relief Society of America this week filed suit in U.S. district court against several Louisiana dioceses, including Baton Rouge and Lafayette, asking a federal judge to declare that it has no liability for current sexual-abuse claim payouts.
The dioceses have sought indemnification from the Nebraska-based mutual for abuse claims. In the complaint, the company states it has “no coverage obligations toward the dioceses, in connection with existing lawsuits or claims, or any future lawsuits or claims,” because “the small amount of limited aggregate coverage” for abuse allegations “has been exhausted.” It says the dioceses or the terms of earlier contracts have already used up that limited aggregate.
Contracts Ended in 2024
Catholic Mutual says it ended its contracts with the Louisiana dioceses in 2024. The federal action is intended to clarify any “ongoing rights and obligations” tied to earlier coverage periods. The organization describes itself as a “church-based mutual benefit organization” that “does not enter into insurance contracts with the public” and therefore argues it is not subject to the Louisiana Insurance Code.
The Diocese of Alexandria was not named in the suit. That diocese recently filed for bankruptcy, and an automatic stay bars claims against it while the case proceeds.
Broader Louisiana Context
About a year ago, the Archdiocese of New Orleans obtained court approval, after five years of litigation, of a $230 million bankruptcy settlement covering some 650 victims. Funding included $130 million in cash from the archdiocese and its affiliates, $20 million in promissory notes, $30 million from insurers, and up to $50 million from property sales.
The new filing underscores the pressure on diocesan finances and on church-related mutuals as civil claims continue. Catholic Mutual seeks a clear judicial determination that its prior limited coverage is exhausted and that it owes nothing further on present or future Louisiana abuse suits, while the named dioceses pursue the indemnification they say is still due under earlier arrangements.