Canadian Priests Urge Clear National Stand on MAiD
Priests say local responses leave pastors struggling with cases of Catholics choosing MAiD and want national pastoral norms.
Canadian priests are pressing for clearer national pastoral direction as Catholics increasingly seek medical assistance in dying (MAiD), calling the practice a moral crisis that cannot be left to local improvisation alone.
Fr. Thomas Lynch, president of Priests for Life Canada and a priest of the Diocese of Peterborough, said a national initiative is urgently needed to confront what he called the “real problem” of Catholics accessing MAiD. The Church “needs to be far clearer,” he said. “It can’t just be diocese by diocese,” nor limited to a letter from the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops (CCCB). Most priests he has spoken with “have experience with Catholic people being killed,” he added, and he refused to use the phrase “dying by MAiD.”
Federal MAiD reporting does not track religious affiliation, so it is impossible to know how many of the 16,499 Canadians who received MAiD in 2024 were practicing or lapsed Catholics.
Pastoral Pressure and Local Cases
Deacon Laurence Worthen, executive director of the Christian Medical and Dental Association of Canada, agreed the situation is “a huge problem.” He called for parish information sheets and preaching on the subject, saying, “We need a full-court press.” This month he is traveling across Canada to address 15 groups on the “moral peril” of MAiD through his association’s three-part program Dying with Christ – Living with Hope.
Two local situations illustrate the pastoral bind. In Vancouver, Fr. Joseph D’Souza of St. Mary Parish refused anointing to an elderly religious sister who planned MAiD and, after consulting the chancery, declined a funeral Mass, offering a graveside blessing instead. In Spruce Grove, Alberta, Fr. Paul Moret of Holy Trinity Church preached on the sanctity of life after reports that two parishioners had died by MAiD, with families allegedly keeping the cause of death secret to obtain funeral Masses.
Moret said his first instinct was that MAiD is wrong in every circumstance. Hearing of pressure and of people turning to it amid inadequate health care has led him to question whether every choice is free. He pointed to the Catechism’s teaching that grave psychological disturbance can diminish responsibility for suicide, and said he would welcome clarification on whether similar factors can shape the pastoral response after a MAiD death.
Church Teaching and Public Opinion
The CCCB has opposed legalized euthanasia since before the 2016 MAiD law. In a June statement marking the tenth anniversary of MAiD, it affirmed that euthanasia and assisted dying “can never be morally acceptable.” Its spokesperson pointed to the free toolkit Horizons of Hope: A Toolkit for Catholic Parishes on Palliative Care and to a Joint Ad hoc Committee on Palliative Care.
A June 2023 Ipsos poll commissioned by the pro-MAiD group Dying with Dignity found Catholic support for MAiD at 83 percent—nearly matching the national 84 percent—for patients whose natural death is reasonably foreseeable. That gap between stated Catholic belief and practice sharpens the call for unified preaching, formation, and pastoral norms rooted in the Church’s constant defense of life from conception to natural death.