Canadian Bishops Urge Split of the MAID Bill
They warn advance requests raise serious ethical and rights concerns and press Parliament to invest in palliative care and supports for the vulnerable.
On November 12, 2026, the Canadian Conference of Catholic Bishops released a parliamentary brief calling on lawmakers to revise Bill C-41, the proposed Medical Assistance in Dying Safeguards Act, and to divide it into two separate measures.
The bishops argue that provisions allowing advance requests for euthanasia raise serious ethical, legal, and human rights concerns. They ask members of Parliament to treat that question apart from the permanent exclusion of mental illness as the sole underlying condition for medical assistance in dying (MAID).
Bill C-41 was introduced in Parliament on October 27, 2026, and is at second reading in the House of Commons. The legislation followed an announcement by Justice Minister Sean Fraser that the government would not move forward with the expansion scheduled in the Criminal Code for MAID in circumstances where mental illness is the sole basis.
Advance Requests and the Vulnerable
In their brief, the bishops contend that advance requests—authorizing MAID at a future moment when a person may no longer be able to confirm consent—pose distinct risks for people living with serious illness, disability, or declining independence. They urge MPs to examine those risks on their own merits rather than package them with the mental-illness exclusion, so that each issue receives full parliamentary scrutiny.
The conference does not frame the debate solely in negative terms. Alongside its objections, it calls for greater public investment in palliative care, health care, and practical supports that help people live with dignity amid serious illness and loss of autonomy. The bishops present that positive agenda as essential if Canada is to protect the vulnerable rather than expand pathways to death.
Church Teaching and Public Responsibility
Catholic teaching holds that the intentional killing of the innocent, including by euthanasia or assisted suicide, is gravely contrary to the dignity of the human person and the fifth commandment. The Canadian bishops’ intervention places that constant teaching in the concrete setting of federal legislation now before the House.
By asking Parliament to split the bill, the conference seeks space for a clearer debate: one track on whether mental illness alone should ever qualify a person for MAID, and another on whether advance directives can ever safely authorize a lethal act when the patient can no longer speak. The bishops’ brief thus presses both a procedural demand and a substantive defense of life at a moment when Canada’s MAID regime remains under active revision.